Skip to content
orgroom
Journal

Button, oyster or shiitake: what to cook with each

Three mushrooms, three textures. A short guide to picking the right one for the dish.

Most recipes say mushrooms and leave it there. The variety you choose changes texture and flavour more than almost any other ingredient swap.

Button: the everyday mushroom

Mild, firm and happy in almost anything. Slice raw into salads, cook into mutter mushroom or a butter masala, top a pizza, or roast whole. Cook on high heat and give them space in the pan so they brown instead of steaming.

Oyster: soft and quick

Oyster mushrooms tear by hand into ribbons and cook in two or three minutes. They suit stir-fries, pakoras, noodles and anything where you want a tender, almost silky bite.

Shiitake: meaty and savoury

Shiitake has a dense texture and deep umami. The stems are tough, so pull them off and add them to stock. Use the caps in soups, ramen, fried rice and anywhere you want the mushroom to lead.

A simple rule

If the mushroom is a supporting player, use button. If texture matters, use oyster. If flavour should lead, use shiitake.

Fresh button mushrooms, harvesting now.

Order from the farm